Shell Earnings: Weaker-Than-Expected Quarter Doesn’t Change Outlook as Repurchases Held Steady

We think Shell stock is fairly valued.

Collage illustration for Energy Sector with a gas pump.

Key Morningstar Metrics for Shell

What We Thought of Shell’s Earnings

Shell SHEL‘s fourth-quarter earnings fell short of market expectations due to the integrated gas and marketing segments. Shell returned 52% of its operating cash flow to shareholders in 2025. It maintained its USD 3.5 billion share repurchase program for the first quarter and increased the dividend 4%.

Why it matters: The weaker-than-expected results stemmed from noncash tax effects from a joint venture in marketing, continued weak chemical margins, and relatively weaker trading results. As such, we see no change in Shell’s trajectory toward improved returns or its commitment to return 40%-50% of cash flow to shareholders.

  • Shell maintained its quarterly repurchase rate, despite its growing debt levels. However, gearing of 20.7% remains within the company’s comfort range of 10%-30%.
  • Cumulative cost reductions rose to USD 5.1 billion at end-2025, leaving Shell on track to achieve the upper end of its target range of USD 5 billion to USD 7 billion by end-2028.

The bottom line: Our EUR 34.20/GBX 2,970 fair value estimates and no moat rating remain unchanged. Shares are modestly undervalued. We continue to view Shell as one of the best options among European integrated oils, given its strategy and execution.

  • Shell continues to present the best combination of valuation, financial health, capital allocation, and asset quality among European integrated oils in our coverage. We have high confidence in management to deliver on existing targets and to push beyond them once achieved.

Editor's Note: This analysis was originally published as a stock note by Morningstar Equity Research.

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar's editorial policies.