The third quarter has been a difficult one for European equities, although the performance of individual stocks has been very different. The Morningstar Europe Index returned -0.6% in euros during the quarter, hiding important differences between companies and sectors.
While some European stocks have fallen, others have continued to perform strongly. In some cases, these gains have taken share prices significantly above Morningstar’s estimate of fair value.
We have therefore looked for European companies that combine two characteristics. First, their shares have performed strongly during the third quarter, above 10% in euros. Second, they have a price/fair value estimate above 1.20, meaning that their shares are at least 20% overvalued.
Here are five European stocks that stand out after their strong performance in the third quarter and their current premium to Morningstar’s fair value.
5 Overvalued Stocks to Avoid in Q4
Key Morningstar Metrics
Soitec SOI
- Sector: Technology
- Industry: Semiconductor Equipment & Materials
- Morningstar Rating: ★
- Price/Fair Value: 2.39
- Morningstar Uncertainty Rating: Very High
Javier Correonero, equity analyst for Morningstar, says:
“Soitec manufactures silicon-on-insulator and other engineered wafers for the semiconductor industry. It buys plain silicon wafers and re-engineers them, adding layers of materials to improve efficiency and reduce power consumption.”
“Weak sales will weigh on margins and capacity utilization in 2027, so management should continue cutting costs where possible. Silicon photonics remains the only product with credible upside potential for the next few years, as data centers need optical transceivers to scale-out performance between racks, converting electrical signals into optical ones.”
Anglo American AAL
- Sector: Basic Materials
- Industry: Other Industrial Metals & Mining
- Morningstar Rating: ★
- Price/Fair Value: 1.81
- Morningstar Uncertainty Rating: High
Jon Mills, equity analyst for Morningstar, says:
“In response to BHP’s unsuccessful bid for the company in May 2024, Anglo American is restructuring to focus on copper, iron ore, and crop nutrients, while selling or spinning off its other businesses. We continue to assume iron ore averages about USD 100 per metric ton from 2026 to 2028 based on the futures curve. Based on our estimate of the long-run marginal cost of production, our assumed midcycle price is around USD 75 per metric ton from 2030. Solid demand from China, which accounts for around 75% of the seaborne iron ore trade, is supportive of near-term prices. However, in the longer term, we expect demand from China to moderate as steel production peaks and starts to decline as its economy moves away from one reliant on fixed-asset investment to a more consumption-based economy.”
A.P. Moller - Maersk MAERSK B
- Sector: Industrials
- Industry: Marine Shipping
- Morningstar Rating: ★★
- Price/Fair Value: 1.48
- Morningstar Uncertainty Rating: High
Ben Slupecki, equity analyst for Morningstar, says:
“Maersk is now a focused global shipper and logistics company after divesting its energy and drilling, banking, and towage businesses in recent years. It is investing heavily to build its logistics and solutions segment, aiming to match the core maritime shipping business in revenue in the future.. We view shares as overvalued, as we anticipate vessel oversupply, since the current order book is at a multidecade high and rerouting needs fade. We also updated our long-term freight rate to reflect continued port congestion, as port infrastructure has not increased at the rate of demand and should continue to reduce supply.”
Equinor EQNR
- Sector: Energy
- Industry: Oil & Gas Integrated
- Morningstar Rating: ★★
- Price/Fair Value: 1.3
- Morningstar Uncertainty Rating: High
Allen Good, equity analyst for Morningstar, says:
“Thanks to its dominant position on the NCS (Norwegian Continental Shelf), Equinor holds some competitive advantages relative to peers. The focus on a single area allowed the firm to gain in-depth knowledge of the region relative to its rivals while building out significant infrastructure that lowered the capital cost of incremental production. However, given a high tax burden in Norway, Equinor has historically failed to match the after-tax upstream earnings margins or returns on capital of its higher quality peers.”
Ocado Group OCDO
- Sector: Consumer Defensive
- Industry: Grocery Stores
- Morningstar Rating: ★★★
- Price/Fair Value: 1.26
- Morningstar Uncertainty Rating: Very High
Verushka Shetty, equity analyst for Morningstar, says:
“Ocado Group offers exposure to the international e-grocery market. It began as a pure-play e-grocer in the UK and was the first mover in end-to-end automated fulfillment in groceries. The pandemic brought significant demand to Ocado Retail and solutions, but e-grocery growth has moderated in recent years. Ocado is in the early stages of expansion, with execution risks ahead. Its client base is concentrated, with the majority of revenue from Ocado Retail and Kroger. Current partners are rethinking commitments made during the pandemic, raising uncertainty about the future of Ocado’s installed base.”

