Key Takeaways
- Investors must be selective as the AI trade risks becoming unsustainable, Rathbones’ David Coombs warns.
- Diversification has been neglected by many investors, with bonds, healthcare and commodities offering attractive opportunities.
- De-globalization could become a leading investment theme in 2027.
Karen Gilchrist: Building a genuinely diversified portfolio is becoming increasingly difficult, with a handful of mega-cap tech stocks dominating equity returns, and rising global bond yields raising questions about their role as a defensive anchor. How should investors be balancing risk and return as we look ahead to 2027? To discuss, I’m joined by David Coombs, head of multi-asset investments at Rathbones. David, thank you so much for joining us.
Now let’s kick-start with the AI boom. Clearly, AI has been dominating equity returns for much of 2026, driving earnings expectations, investment, and valuation. Just how sustainable do you think this growth is?
David Coombs: It’s unsustainable, in big-picture terms, OK. Because there are some similarities with previous kind of technological surges, such as dot-com—and I don’t want to go down that rabbit hole necessarily—but what tends to happen is capital starts chasing returns. You’ve got some significant geopolitical risks and macro risks in the world, and therefore AI has been kind of the only growth story this year, which is why it’s kind of dominating.
Now, it is exciting its own right, but when it’s the only growth story, it’s sucking in lots of capital. And what typically happens is that capital starts kind of being squeezed into more speculative areas of that particular story. I think we’re seeing that. We’re seeing massive capital raising from the Magnificent Seven or Four or Six, whatever it is today. So you’ve got the credit markets kind of getting much bigger because of that issuance. You’ve got valuations being pushed. Is that sustainable? No. It will revert to the fundamentals at some stage. That’s what we believe. And you’ve got to be very careful and selective where you put your capital. The market has been less selective this year.
Avoiding the ‘Kodaks’ of AI
Karen Gilchrist: So how do you distinguish between some of the long-term winners and then those that are just sort of benefiting from this recent frenzy? I know you’ve spoken about kind of avoiding the ‘Kodak’ sort of fallout as well.
David Coombs: Yeah, I mean, I do think, like always, when you have a revolution, whatever that might be, there will be spectacular failure, and there will be capital written off. And if I knew each one, I’d be a star, right? But what we’re trying to do is look throughout the entire AI buildout, from the most basic power right through to the most complex chips, and looking at different companies along that production where there are real earnings right now. It’s not speculative—the market may be speculating on next year’s and following year’s—but there are definitely some earnings.
And what we’ve tried to do is look at those companies in each part of the chain that have a technological edge, whether it’s a TSMC 2330 or an ASML ASML, rather than buying companies that are producing chips, but they may be more commoditized. There’s less of a technological edge, maybe more threat of new entrants. Because what we also know about a big kind of theme such as this, you do attract all these new entrants who want to play the game, and it’s really important you’re in those companies that have got that moat. Because when you get that volatility in the market, you want to be in the companies that survive and then survive that kind of readdressing of value, if you like. But it’s going to be, it’s going to be volatile.
Karen Gilchrist: You mentioned some of the semiconductor stocks or the ASMLs and the like. How about the picks-and-shovels side? Are there any names to highlight there?
David Coombs: Yeah, I mean we, it’s a very strange trade, because Caterpillar CAT, which you would you think would be—well, it makes bulldozers and trucks—became part of the AI-adjacent trade. People talk about the AI-adjacent trade. What’s that all about? And that’s exactly what I’m talking about. You start getting theories and stories around adjacent sectors. Utilities companies have become growth stocks because they’re building JV (joint venture) data centers with the Mag Seven. We’ve got to stop saying the Mag Seven: The hyperscalers. I hate that term as well, actually, but anyway. And so the whole market, every sector has got AI winners.
I think the most interesting part, though, and the most difficult part, is who are the long-term winners? Who are going to be enabled by AI with new products, new services that are going to be new to market, are going to be the Apples AAPL or the Googles GOOGL of 2028, 2029, 2030? I don’t know who they are yet. I’d love to sit here and tell you what they are, but that’s what you’re looking for. And it could be existing companies that are quite boring that will just transcend their business and suddenly they have super growth. But that’s the exciting part, and I think market hasn’t really looked there yet.
Diversify Beyond AI in Healthcare and Consumer Stocks
Karen Gilchrist: Zooming out from some of those hyperscaler names, those big mega-cap stocks, how can investors really think about building a genuinely diversified portfolio? Do you have any advice for how they do that without necessarily missing out, hopefully, on some of these big rallies?
David Coombs: I think, first of all, you do need to have exposure to AI, right? There is no doubt it is going to become ubiquitous. It will be like water or electricity, right? It will literally affect every company you invest in. It’ll affect government expenditure. It’s going to be across the entire portfolio. Where you want to be investing in AI, be precise. Like I said, we invest in networks that provide connectors within the stacks and data centers. We own advanced tests, there’s the chip testing. You want to be very specific, and then make sure the rest of your portfolio is genuinely diversified. And those AI-adjacent stocks I talked about, make sure that your entire portfolio is not in those that have been carried up on the hype.
Valuation is always important long-term; often isn’t short term, to be fair. But make sure you’ve got genuine diversification, because diversification has gone really out of fashion this year. All I hear is people (saying): returns, returns, returns. And if you’re in a portfolio at the moment that hasn’t kept up, you’re being criticized. But, actually, that’s probably the right portfolio. You want to have genuine diversification in your portfolio. Look at those sectors that have been really underperforming for the last 2 or 3 years. Healthcare, medical technology, for example. Consumer has been awful because of higher interest rates. And they’re not very exciting at the moment, but actually that’s probably where we should be looking for that diversification.
Bonds Continue to Look Attractive
Karen Gilchrist: OK. Now bonds used to be the great diversifier, but with spiraling government debt and rising inflation, that’s called that slightly into question, that safe-haven aspect. So does that still sort of stand or are governments now one of the main sources of risk?
David Coombs: Both. I mean, I think they are a clear source of risk. No one seems to be really seriously wanting to address deficits. I think there is a difference, though, because we now have yields north of 5%, near 6% in longer-dated bonds. You are being paid for that risk. And inflation, yes, it’s elevated at three-and-a-half, three (percent), whichever measure you look at. There are real returns to be had, if it doesn’t get worse. That’s a big if, but you are, for the first time in probably 20 years, being paid a real return for holding government bonds.
I’m not saying it’s, you know, it’s an absolute shoo-in but my fixed-income portfolio is almost all government bonds. But what I’ve been doing is diversifying. I don’t want all my kind of chips with Andy Burnham and Healey. So I’m owning New Zealand, Australia, Norway, US index-linked bonds. So have a real spread. They’re highly liquid. If we do get a big correction, I think deficits won’t matter, government bonds will rally and provide that diversification. But it’s not a slam dunk, right. But they still have a role to play in my view.
Increasing Gilt Exposure Ahead of UK Budget
Karen Gilchrist: You mentioned the UK, and you reduced exposure to UK gilts earlier in the year amid all the political uncertainty. We’ve now had Andy Burnham in situ for several months, and we’re looking forward to this budget from Chancellor John Healey. Looking forward, maybe not the case, but how has your view on the UK market adjusted?
David Coombs: It hasn’t changed significantly. We have been buying some shorter-dated gilts in the last few weeks, partially because I sense that the government does get it, but is nervous about saying it. I think the one positive thing I would say compared to last year, we haven’t seen all these policies being floated in advance, which was really unhelpful for creating speculation.
I think that’s a sign to me that there’s a bit more kind of, a sensible hand on the tiller. So that’s helpful. So I’ve been adding gilts. I’m still mostly adding at the shorter end, which is less risky. Yeah. And because again, if you’re getting 5%, 5.5% versus cash, that still looks quite attractive at the moment, and I think will provide diversification. So we have been adding but I’m still below—I mean, to get technical—I’m underweight duration versus the market, I’m not going long yet.
Karen Gilchrist: Earlier in the year you were also fairly bearish on corporate bonds and noting that spreads had tightened, and also that investors were being insufficiently compensated, particularly by some of these hyperscalers that are investing massively. What is your approach now? Has that adjusted at all?
David Coombs: It hasn’t. It’s not that I’m bearish, necessarily. I think the total return is actually quite attractive. And if I was running a benchmark-type fund, I would have corporate bonds. But I’m not, I’m running, you know, an absolute return fund, so I don’t need to own any asset class. And right now, if I look at investing in companies, I just think the risk/reward for equities is better than it is for corporate bonds. I compare corporate bonds to equities rather than to government bonds. I’m getting a decent yield for government bonds. But I also get that liquidity, which allows me to be very flexible. In a market that’s extremely volatile, liquidity is your friend. Whereas corporate bonds are less liquid. If you want to get out, it’s much more difficult. And so I want to retain that flexibility to be active at the moment.
Commodities Offer an Inflation Hedge
Karen Gilchrist: OK, makes sense. Now thinking beyond equities and fixed-income, are there any other sort of asset classes that you’re now choosing as an optimum time?
David Coombs: Yeah, I mean apart from just derivatives and buying protection, you know, we have interest rate protection, we have put options on the Nasdaq. But outside of that the interesting areas really are commodities. Because, if you think about it, everyone says to me what are the safe havens? There is no such thing as a safe haven; we need to overcome that, right. What there are are risk mitigators. As in, what are you worried about? And if you’re worried about inflation breaking out, well, I think that’s unlikely, because I do think central banks, in the main, are kind of on top of it. We’ll see, but I think they are. And once the oil price hopefully comes down, if Iran hopefully comes to a cessation.
But if you are worried about inflation—I mentioned US indexing bonds is one avenue and they’ve been looking quite attractive—but I think you want to own the causes of inflation. And particularly in the UK, where we’re an import economy, effectively, we import all our resources coming in, then let’s own copper. Let’s own industrial metals. Let’s own energy, oil. Because I think that just kind of diversifies your risk in case of inflation. Now it’s not my core thesis that inflation will go to 4% or 5%, but I’m not so sure that I don’t want some diversification to offset that, if it were to happen.
Markets To Broaden Out Beyond AI in 2027
Karen Gilchrist: OK. And now looking ahead to 2027, what is your sort of central forecast for global markets? Where do you see opportunities, and what are some of the risks that could really derail that?
David Coombs: Crikey, there are so many, and this is a short interview. So I guess for 2027 I mean it’s going to be more of the same, right, which is not very exciting. You know, AI is multidecade. I do think the markets will start to focus on other themes. And one of the big themes I think is really important, that’s not getting enough traction, is this row back from globalization. I do think the Trump-led protectionism is being increasingly met with protectionism from Europe, from Canada, from other countries, and tit-for-tat. I think those that think if Trump is a lame duck president next year, or if the Democrats win in two years’ time in the White House, that that will suddenly go back to where we were, I don’t believe that is true. I think this is a multiyear issue.
You’re going to see more and more governments looking to support national industries in key areas, where they need security, whether that’s food, energy, cyber, defense. I think those will be areas of real interest that we need to be looking to. And also healthcare has been an awful place to invest. But again, we’ve still got aging populations. We’ve still got governments that can’t afford to look after the healthcare of their, their citizens, and we’ve got to make efficiencies there. So maybe this is hope over forecast, is kind of how I’m positioning. But I do believe at some stage the markets will start to broaden out from just the AI trade. For that to happen though, we need to see the end to the Strait of Hormuz conflict, and we need interest rates and inflation to start coming down. Until that happens, we’re stuck in the hamster wheel of doom, I think.
Karen Gilchrist: David Coombs, on that note, thank you so much. For Morningstar, I’m Karen Gilchrist.
