What Does France’s Debt Crisis Mean for Banking Stocks?

The country’s fiscal woes have weighed on Paris-listed banking stocks, but analysts still see value among the key names.

Sign at the entrance to a BNP Paribas offices.
Erik McGregor/LightRocket via Getty

Key Takeaways

  • France’s three biggest listed banking stocks have underperformed European peers in recent weeks, as debt concerns rattled investors.
  • Next year’s presidential election adds to the uncertainty around France’s fiscal future.
  • Morningstar’s Johann Scholtz sees value in French banks, but he expects a “bumpy ride” for shares.

France’s debt crisis has piled pressure on domestic banking stocks in recent weeks, with share prices falling sharply. While the country’s three biggest banks under Morningstar coverage now screen as undervalued, analysts say investors should expect volatility because of ongoing political uncertainty.

BNP Paribas BNP shares are 10% in the red over the past month, Société Générale GLE has declined 13%, and Crédit Agricole ACA has fallen by around 12%. All three have underperformed the Morningstar Developed Markets Europe Banks - Regional Index, which is down nearly 8% over one month.

TwentyFour Asset Management portfolio manager Jakub Lichwa says banks “always find themselves in the crossfire when there is pressure on their domestic sovereign debt,” as the assets on their balance sheets tend to be closely linked to the strength of the underlying economy. That’s why French banks have underperformed their European peers in recent weeks, he adds.

Concerns have grown around France’s ability to control its record-high debt position, particularly as next year’s presidential election presents more policy uncertainty for the country’s economy. France’s fiscal woes have put its government bonds, known as OATs, at the center of a wider sovereign debt selloff. This has pushed up yields on the 10-year OAT to their highest point since 2002, at 4.85% as of Oct. 12.

The spread over German Bunds has attracted even more attention, as it shows the additional return investors demand to hold French OATs versus safer German government debt. The difference in OAT-Bund yields reached 155 basis points as of Oct. 2—its widest since 2011, during the eurozone crisis. Indeed, the situation has drawn comparisons to the bloc’s sovereign debt crisis, due to fears of financial contagion. Investor jitters have dragged the euro to its lowest point against the dollar since May 2025; it’s at EUR 1.1176 as of Oct. 12.

As fiscal risks loom over France’s economy, what does this mean for Paris-listed banking stocks?

Are French Bank Stocks Still Investible?

Morningstar senior equity analyst Johann Scholtz says French banks “still look attractive at current prices.” BNP Paribas, Société Générale, and Crédit Agricole all hold 4-star ratings, meaning they are considered undervalued. At the same time, he warns investors can expect a “bumpy ride,” and he anticipates banking shares will stay volatile, as political uncertainty is likely to keep yields elevated.

France’s Political Uncertainty and the Budget

France’s highly polarized political landscape going into next year’s presidential election adds to the complexity of its fiscal situation. The latest survey from pollster Toluna-Harris Interactive sees far-right National Rally leader Marine Le Pen facing hard-left France Unbowed leader Jean-Luc Mélenchon in a second-round runoff vote in May in all five scenarios laid out in the poll.

The country has been trapped in political gridlock since incumbent president Emmanuel Macron called a snap election in 2024, with the minority government under pressure to get its 2027 budget passed through parliament and ease bond market nerves. The French government proposed EUR 43 billion of spending cuts in its budget, submitted at the start of October, as it seeks to reduce its deficit to 5% of economic output in 2027. The budget deficit is expected to climb to 5.4% in 2026 (up from 5.1% in 2025), one of the highest in the euro area.

“Much of the rise in French government bond yields reflects investors demanding extra compensation for France’s fiscal position,” says Scholtz. He points out that French banks hold a lot of domestic government debt, and that its market value falls when yields rise. “However, most of these bonds are held to maturity to match money owed to depositors,” he says. “Unless the bonds are sold, those losses don’t flow through to profits.”

French Bank Earnings Are Due Soon

BNP Paribas’ profits jumped by a third in the second quarter versus the same period last year, according to results released in July. That same month, Société Générale reported record quarterly group net income for the second three months of its financial year, while Crédit Agricole’s second-quarter earnings came in above forecasts.

These banks report earnings on the following dates:

  • BNP Paribas: Oct. 28
  • Société Générale: Oct. 29
  • Crédit Agricole: Oct. 30

While these banks hold significant government debt, Scholtz says they are also less exposed to the domestic economy than many investors assume. France makes up around a quarter of BNP Paribas’ revenue, and it accounts for just under half for Société Générale and Crédit Agricole. He says having large businesses in wider Europe and beyond cushions them from a weaker French economy. In addition, Scholtz highlights that previous spikes in French yields have had “little direct effect on bank profits, but weighed on the shares.”

Risks to Watch for French Banks

Looking ahead, JPMorgan analysts said in a note published on Oct.5 that they expect investor appetite for French bank stocks to “remain capped until the political and sovereign risks fade.” Of the French banks, they wrote that BNP Paribas was their preferred pick, partly due to its lower exposure to France and “upside to still low capital distribution expectations.” JPM has an overweight rating on BNP Paribas, a neutral rating on Société Générale, and it’s underweight Crédit Agricole.

Considering possible risks, Morningstar’s Scholtz says that if the French government seeks ways to raise revenue, it could increase taxes on banks or large companies.

TwentyFour AM’s Lichwa similarly says a bigger fiscal budget could lead to “unpredictable policy responses, raising the risk of new or higher banking taxes … [or] changes to regulated savings products such as Livret A, which may impact bank margins.”

Scholtz says another risk is that if France’s credit rating is cut, banks’ borrowing costs could also rise, “because their ratings are closely tied to the sovereign’s.”

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar's editorial policies.