Key Morningstar Metrics for Porsche
- Fair Value Estimate: EUR 46
- Morningstar Rating: ★★★
- Morningstar Economic Moat Rating: Narrow
- Morningstar Uncertainty Rating: Very High
What We Thought of Porsche’s Earnings
Porsche P911 reported an operating loss of negative EUR 966 million and an underlying operating profit of just under EUR 1.2 billion for the third quarter, implying an underlying margin in line with the company’s medium-term guidance for a double-digit margin.
Why it matters: We think the solid underlying profit result will drive market expectations for a quicker recovery to double-digit margins. In line with management’s more cautious tone, we expect a return to double-digit margins only in 2028.
- China remains a weak point for Porsche, with weaker sales results expected again in 2026. This will hold back group volumes in 2026 to levels below 2025.
- While larger price increases are being implemented in the US relative to the rest of the world, we continue to expect a large portion of the tariff burden to fall on Porsche in 2026.
The bottom line: We maintain our fair value estimate of EUR 46 for narrow-moat Porsche. We view the shares as fairly valued at current levels.
- Our forecast already includes a significant recovery in profitability in 2026, with the exclusion of significant one-off costs, to a high-single-digit underlying margin.
- We welcome the company’s decision to appoint a new CEO, former McLaren CEO and Ferrari CTO Michael Leiters, a leader who is 100% focused on the Porsche business. While Leiters has years of experience at Porsche before his tenure at Ferrari, a leadership transition may bring further strategic adjustments. Leiters has been vocal in his views that electric vehicle technology is not yet ready to be used in supercars.

