Canadian Pacific Earnings: Fuel Tempers Margins, but Volume Growth and Core Productivity Solid

Canadian Pacific’s adjusted operating ratio deteriorated due to fuel-related noise.

Signage is pictured at a Canadian Pacific Kansas City (CPKC) rail yard in Smiths Falls, Ontario.
Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press via AP

Key Morningstar Metrics for Canadian Pacific Kansas City

  • Fair Value Estimate
    : C$104.00
  • Morningstar Rating
    : ★★
  • Morningstar Economic Moat Rating
    : Wide
  • Morningstar Uncertainty Rating
    : Medium

What We Thought of Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s Earnings

Canadian Pacific Kansas City’s CP third-quarter revenue spiked 15% year over year on higher carloads and strong all-in yield gains (surging fuel surcharges, positive core pricing) and higher total volumes, including carloads and intermodal. Adjusted consolidated margin fell, mostly due to fuel noise.

Why it matters: Carloads—excluding intermodal—grew 3% year over year on robust grain and strong metals activity, partly driven by new business wins, but offset by lower coal (mine production) and automotive (manufacturer production holds) shipments.

  • Intermodal volume flipped strongly positive year over year, rising 9%, on solid domestic and international activity. We suspect good service levels (for truck-to-rail conversions) and new business wins contributed. It sounds as if the Mexico-Midwest Express and CSX-partnered Southeast-Midwest Express offerings saw volumes build in the quarter.
  • Canadian Pacific’s adjusted operating ratio (expenses/revenue, excluding amortization) deteriorated to 61.9%, due to fuel-related noise, namely surcharge mix and (to a lesser degree) lag—roughly a 190-basis-point impact. That said, management still expects low-double-digit adjusted earnings-per-share growth this year thanks to healthy volume growth, solid underlying productivity trends, and share buybacks.

The bottom line: We maintain our fair value estimate for wide-moat Canadian Pacific, as our longer-term model forecast will likely remain intact.

  • After rallying (along with most rails) in the first half on rebounding intermodal demand and improving industrial sector demand, we think the shares are modestly overvalued relative to our long-term free cash flow forecasts. Investors are willing to pay up for Canadian Pacific’s favorable near-term growth prospects and healthy profitability profile.

Editor's Note: This analysis was originally published as a stock note by Morningstar Equity Research.

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar's editorial policies.