Can Canada’s Stock Market Stay Ahead of the US?

Canadian stocks are narrowly leading US stocks in the final months of 2026, and analysts are cautiously optimistic.

Bay street in Toronto, Canada.
pictore via Getty

Key Takeaways

  • Canadian stocks are on track for a second straight year of outperforming US equities.
  • The market’s sectoral composition has helped it surge amid geopolitical turmoil and a fragile economy, analysts say.
  • Some observers are cautious about the outlook for continued Canadian stock market outperformance.

With less than two months left in 2026, Canadian stocks are holding gains, outpacing the US stock market for the second year running. While the margin is narrower than in 2025, Canadian stocks’ heavy exposure to energy, materials, and financials has helped them weather global turmoil and edge ahead of their counterparts in the United States, where a sputtering AI trade has slowed momentum.

The Morningstar Canada Index is up more than 13% for the year through Nov. 2, narrowly ahead of the Morningstar US Total Market Index’s 10% gain. For the same period, the S&P/TSX Composite Index has posted a nearly 12% gain, compared with the S&P 500’s more than 10% rise. In 2025, Canadian stocks gained more than 29%, while US equities rose some 15%.

“These are the golden years,” for Canadian stocks, says Garey Aitken, head of Canadian equities at Franklin Templeton’s ClearBridge Investments. “If the Canadian market could even get to 20% by year-end, that would be no small feat.”

Ben Jang, portfolio manager at Nicola Wealth, expects Canadian stocks to hold their lead through the end of 2026. Still, a “roughly 2 percentage point [lead] is real, but it can disappear in one bad week, particularly for oil or the banks.”

The Canadian Market’s Makeup Drives Its Momentum

The market’s performance is primarily shaped by its composition, according to Franklin Templeton’s Aitken. “The big three sectors—financials, energy, and materials—probably represent more than two-thirds of the S&P/TSX Composite, [and] for their own idiosyncratic reasons, they’ve been really strong,” he says. “At one time or another in the last couple of years, they’ve provided such leadership that it’s enabled the Canadian market to do as well as it has.”

The energy sector has particularly gained thanks to higher prices stemming from the conflict in the Middle East. Meanwhile, investor concerns over government debt, higher inflation, and financial stability drove up gold prices, benefiting basic materials.

“The same kind of global instability that’s rattling most markets has worked in Canada’s favor,” says Theresa Shutt, chief investment officer at Harbourfront Wealth Management. “In a way, Canada’s stock market is becoming a natural hedge against this noise or messiness, even if Canada’s economy isn’t.”

Can Canadian Stocks Continue to Outperform?

Analysts temper their cheery market outlook by acknowledging potential risks that could derail its momentum. Franklin Templeton’s Aitken points to higher interest rates as a potential headwind for the overall market. Last week, the Bank of Canada delivered its first interest rate hike in three years, raising its policy rate by a quarter point to 2.50% from 2.25%. “Inflation is still stubborn or sticky, and policymakers seem to be leaning towards wanting to address that with higher rates,” he says. “At some point, you could get to a point where equity markets really start to have a problem with higher rates.”

The ongoing trade turmoil is another uncertainty casting a shadow on the market’s year-end gains. “We’ve got a couple of months for [trade tensions] to re-escalate, and if we know anything about Trump, it’s the unpredictability of that escalation,” says Nicola Wealth’s Jang. “Even though there’s only a couple of months left, he could revisit that aggressively.”

Jang is cautiously optimistic about financials, the second-best-performing sector in 2026 and more than a third of the Morningstar Canada Index. Bank stocks are “not as cheap as they were before, and we think going forward, it’ll be a balance between margin expansion and earnings growth,” he says.

“On the margin, higher rates help with the margin banks earn on deposits,” Jang says. At the same time, “they obviously hurt mortgage holders ... and businesses that we’ve seen are readily struggling with different situations, tariffs, and the weakening economy. So it’s this balance to be had, but shorter term, we think it still favors the banks.”

Beyond banks, the valuation story appears more positive for Canada than the US market. The Canada Index trades at a price/earnings ratio of 15.18, offering a 21% valuation discount to the US Total Market Index’s multiple of 19.16.

“Canadian stocks are trading at more attractive multiples and valuations,” says Harbourfront’s Shutt. “That obviously makes them more attractive and could bring more flows.” She adds that in the US, valuations are at their peak, whereas “Canada still has some room to grow.”

Meanwhile, Shutt says a resolution to the Iran war, however unlikely, could dramatically hit the Canadian stock market. “If a ceasefire comes about, oil prices would drop, and gold, which is a reserve asset or a flight-to-safety holding, could sell down,” she explains. “The TSX could lose both of its engines all at once.”

Aitken questions the staying power of the Canadian market’s outperformance: “Do we see that persisting? This is not sustainable. This will not happen over the next three to five years.” He cautions that investors may be complacent after getting equity returns in the range of 15%-25% a year. “We know that can’t go on forever.”

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar's editorial policies.